An Excess Returns Tax for Canada
A discussion paper for the Department of Finance proposing a targeted tax on the surplus profits of Canada’s largest and least competitive firms.
Submission · Aug 2026
Canada faces a federal deficit of about $80 billion while corporate profits remain strong, and unusually high in a handful of concentrated industries. This discussion paper proposes taxing only the profit a large company earns above a fair return on its invested capital, leaving ordinary and mid-sized businesses untouched.
It estimates that a well-designed Excess Returns Tax could raise roughly $8 to $15 billion a year, sets out the main risks (setting the fair-return line, profit shifting, and investor messaging) and how to manage them, and recommends using the framework Canada applied to the 2022 bank and insurer surtax.
A discussion paper for the Department of Finance, Lalani Consulting Group, August 31, 2026.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.