Enterprise Risk Management – Comprehensive Actuarial Risk Review
This article discusses a comprehensive framework for a comprehensive actuarial risk review (CARR).
Ideas Letter · Vol. 58 · Nov 2014
Background
Enterprises seldom hire actuaries, or actuarial consultants, to undertake a CARR; there are two key reasons for this: 1. Enterprises do not recognize actuaries as risk management professionals, and 2. Enterprises are not aware of a CARR. Actuaries are experts in the mathematics of finance and risk management with rigorous education in understanding risk, business complexities and uncertainties. This expertise is supplemented by the fact that all qualified actuaries belong to a recognized professional body – the Canadian Institute of Actuaries - which has an established code of conduct. The CARR is a rigorous, complete and well documented risk review report that meets generally accepted actuarial standards. The CARR is comprehensive because it provides risk perspectives that meet the needs of different stakeholders – boards, senior management, investors, customers and employees.
Comprehensive Actuarial Risk Review
The CARR attempts to assess risk from specific perspectives - what part(s) of an enterprise, or which stakeholders are assuming or relinquishing risk, and what are the consequences ( losses, or gains that are lower than expectations). The actuary uses quantitative analysis to provide potential variability of the outcome and likely consequences measured in metrics (e.g., ROE, RONA, etc.) commonly used by the enterprise. Many risk practitioners use models without a good understanding of their limitations or underlying assumptions. In a comprehensive review, the actuary reviews the process risk (guidance on the size of the data sample for meaningful and robust results), specification risk (source of systemic error due to use of erroneous use of a statistical distribution to represent the underlying risk) and parameter selection risk (selection and use of incorrect or faulty parameters used in the model). The actuary also provides guidance on emerging risks and low frequency risks which are not sufficiently modelled, or there is no clear statistical or mathematical relationship to measure such risks.
Most enterprises have a risk appetite statement - an expression of the enterprise’s willingness or capacity to take risk to achieve its strategic objectives. For a risk appetite statement to be meaningful, the risk must be defined in an explicit manner – frequency, severity and time horizon. The actuary assists in the review and development of a risk appetite that provides a practical and quantitative framework – the actuary’s framework provides a more balanced perspective as it articulates and incorporate the bottom-up input from the business units into the risk appetite statement and supplements the top-down process developed by senior management and the Board. Different stakeholders have a different perspective on risk. The actuary provides a more holistic and complete view of risk, that is, the actuary evaluates different dimensions of risk – market value vs fundamental value, accounting basis vs economic basis, known risk vs emerging risk, in a CARR.
Ideas in Action
Enterprises should engage their actuaries in undertaking an objective risk review and preparing a CARR.
Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter February 2013, Volume 38.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.