Home / Ideas Letter

Governance Risk – Committee Composition and Dynamics

This article discusses committee composition and dynamics resulting in minimizing governance risk.

Ideas Letter · Vol. 4 · May 2010

Background

Corporate and pension committees usually consist of like-minded individuals with similar backgrounds and perspectives; It is a well documented fact that youthful members, women and minorities bring different perspectives and viewpoints on specific issues. The lack of diversity and the resulting dynamics within a committee results in downside governance risk.

Committee Risk

New members are nominated, or appointed on a committee usually by the chairperson of the committee, or other committee members – the result is a homogeneous committee. Such a committee tends to exhibit the following characteristics: 1. Social cohesion or herding, that is, the social pressure and psychology that creates group think over developing personal insights, and the pressure to conform and behave in presence of others 2. Social loafing, that is, members putting less effort to participating and intervening in committee discussions, which result in sub-optimal decision making

Ideas in Action

Committees must be appointed by a nominating committee (with significant external representation) which has clear understanding of the mandate, roles and responsibilities of the committee. The committee must be selected on meritocratic principles but also incorporate diversity by experience, ethnicity, geography and gender. The selection of a good chairperson is imperative since the chairperson of a committee accepts a tremendous personal responsibility for the outcome and decisions taken at the committee level.

The chairperson must stick to an agenda and related priorities ensure that members make relevant, clear and intelligent decisions, encourage members to speak out, and develop an approval process that is acceptable to all members. In our view, senior or outspoken members should not be allowed to stall discussions, or dominate decision making; it is a fact that members tend to defer to others who may be endorsing an idea with the expectation that the issue and related viewpoint is unchallenged. The chairperson should facilitate an effective meeting so that all viewpoints are discussed. All committee meetings must be well document describing the rationale that contributed to certain key decisions with an executive summary of important discussions and decisions.

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.

↑