Pension Risk Management – Target Benefit Plan Risks
This article discusses Target Benefits Plans (TBPs) and potential risks inherent in TBPs.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 52 · Apr 2014
Background
Recently, TBPs have become a significant focus for pension practitioners, DB plan sponsors and regulators. Most of these stakeholders believe that TBPs may be the solution for achieving sustainable retirement income for members with Defined Benefit (DB) plans suffering financial hardship, and/or with significant solvency funding issues. In its simple form, a TBP has fixed contributions and a targeted benefit formula, with a funding policy that aims to achieve the desired targeted benefits within well-defined tolerance targets including a benefit policy that prescribes a method for varying the targeted benefit formula based on pre-set financial measures and pre-determined order of benefit adjustments. In our view, any plan whether a DC plan, DB plan, a TBP, or any combination of a DB or DC Plan is an acceptable plan design as long as it is consistent with the plan sponsor’s pension philosophy and objectives, and within the plan’s and enterprise risk policy (e.g. risk appetite and risk tolerance).
Understanding Strategic Risk
TBP risks can be broadly classified (in no order of importance) as follows: Actuarial, Benefit, Funding, Governance, Investment and Operational. For this article, we will focus on three of the key risks.
- Actuarial Risk: Actuaries are usually tasked with designing TBP working internally with Human Resource and Finance departments of the plan sponsor. Theoretically, the determination of fixed contributions to fund, or provide targeted benefit formula is simple and straightforward. In practice, there is tension and fine balance with these determination as the ‘numbers’ are based on actuarial assumptions and methodology which are subjective. For purposes of these ‘umbers’, it is important to use acceptable actuarial methodology and best estimate assumptions, subsequently ‘adding’ a margin for adverse deviations. These best estimate assumptions and the margins should be monitored at least annually.
- Funding Risk: The best estimate assumptions should be based on tested and proven asset-liability matching (using both duration and cash flow) techniques including stochastic / scenario testing. To ensure that the benefit liability remains close to 100% covered, a scenario-tested margin and a margin for adverse deviation should be added. In our view, a TBP should have a very high probability of providing the targeted benefit despite the fact the TBP has the ability to adjust (reduce) benefits.
-Investment Risk: The return on assets and the volatility in the assets will impact the financial condition of the TBP and security of benefits. Therefore, it is imperative that assets are managed consistent with the liability benchmark with a low volatility bias. High volatility in the asset portfolio could result in benefit reduction in accordance with the benefits policy due to impact of undesired short-term volatility.
Ideas in Action
DB plan sponsors planning a move from a DB plan to a TBP should confirm their decision by ensuring it is consistent with the plan sponsor’s pension philosophy and objectives and the plan’s and/or enterprise risk policy. If these documents are not available, DB Plan sponsors will serve themselves better by clearly developing their pension philosophy and objectives, and risk policy before embarking on a TBP exercise. Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter September 2013, Volume 45.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.