Home / Ideas Letter

Pension Risk - Managing Defined Benefit Plan Pension Provisions

This article highlights optimizing pension risk by managing pension provisions in a defined benefit plan.

Ideas Letter · Vol. 45 · Sep 2013

Background

Target Benefit Plans (TBP), which aim to provide a target income in retirement but do not guarantee it, are currently the "go-to" plans to replace Defined Contribution (DC) pension plans, or Defined Benefit (DB) pension plans. The stated advantages of TBP discussed in literature: reducing pension income, or temporarily eliminating conditional benefits (future indexing) if the plan doesn’t have enough assets to provide these benefits. Unfortunately, the obvious disadvantage of TBP is lost in these discussions: the uncertainty of pension income and lack of a pension promise, or guarantee may not be appropriate for retired employees as they do not have the ability to supplement their reduced retired income, and provide for loss of purchasing power due to increase in cost of living during their retirement years.

Managing Defined Benefit Plan Provisions

Pension plan sponsors embarking on replacing their DB pension plans should ensure that this decision is based on well articulated and documented pension philosophy and objectives, and avoiding "herd risk" (the downside risk of implementing mainstream actions and strategies that have little or no alignment to the company’s philosophy, strategic intent, objectives and risk appetite ). Simply put, if the DB pension plan is the appropriate plan based on the pension philosophy, then DB pension plan provisions must be reviewed as a solution to managing costs before taking the bold step to transitioning to a new pension plan design. Typically, in DB pension plans, the following plan provisions must be reviewed:

Contribution rates: If there is some or no cost sharing, there may be opportunity to increase the employee share to cover a portion of the past unfunded deficits, and/or increase future contributions.

Pension accrual: If the current pension accrual formula is expected to provide retirement income in excess of the articulated pension objective, the pension formula can be scaled back prospectively.

Survivor benefits: Most pension plans provide survivor benefits exceeding the legislated minimum death benefits. The DB pension plan should be revised to provide legislated benefits, and such benefits should be integrated with other survivor benefits payable from the employer sponsored group plans.

Early Retirement: The DB Pension plans pay generous early retirement benefits which are typically fully paid by the employer. There may be opportunity to share the cost of early retirement benefits with employees, or reducing early retirement subsidies by introducing actuarially equivalent benefits.

Indexing: The cost of living (COL) increases included in pensions in payment are a significant cost. Again there is opportunity to share the cost with employees, or developing an "excess interest" approach of paying COL when the plan has the assets, or the ability to pay such COL increases.

Ideas in Action

All decisions must be based on the plan sponsor's pension philosophy and objectives. All solutions, including a review of pension plan provisions, must be undertaken to managing plan costs. The optimal solution may be "staring you in the face" but the "power of the herd" could be blindsiding your decision.

Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter February 2013, Volume 38.

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.

↑