Home / Ideas Letter

Pension Risk – Pension Plan CARR

Pension plans are highly regulated in Canadian jurisdictions, but the level of scrutiny on assessing risk within a pension plan vary significantly - from having a regulatory risks assessment framework to having no framew

Ideas Letter · Vol. 38 · Feb 2013

Background

Pension plans are highly regulated in Canadian jurisdictions, but the level of scrutiny on assessing risk within a pension plan vary significantly - from having a regulatory risks assessment framework to having no framework. These risk review frameworks have the best of intentions but they rely on data gathered from traditional sources - Annual Information Returns, Audited Financial Statements, Actuarial Valuation Reports and Plan documentation. Such reviews provide a cursory cataloguing of risk issues at a point in time (e.g., non-remittance of contributions, solvency ratios below a threshold, etc.) within a pension plan, but do not provide a 'deep' understanding of pension risks; in other words, the review does not capture the causes, impacts or actions necessary to mitigate, or transfer risk. As an example, a pension plan with no solvency deficit based on a triennial valuation at a point in time does not mean that the plan has no risks. Currently, the enterprises with pension plans, pension committees and pension board trustees have a fragmented, incomplete and inconsistent understanding of the pension plan's risk landscape and, in most cases, the reporting is for regulatory compliance rather than risk management purposes. From a robust risk management perspective, there is a need for a Comprehensive Actuarial Risk Review (CARR) for pension plan.

Pension CARR

A pension CARR must be prepared by a qualified pension actuary who also has certification in risk management; this means that the final product (CARR report) would be precise, complete, well documented and meet accepted actuarial practice. The CARR report would also incorporate standalone Pension Risk Report Summaries (PRRS) for reporting at pension committees/trustees or board meetings, as well as a tool to control the underlying pension risk. For corporations that have Enterprise Risk Management (ERM), the pension CARR can be holistically incorporated in the enterprise wide framework. Typically, the pension CARR project would commence with development of a pension risk framework if none exists. If a pension risk framework does exist, then the next step is the identification of the material risks; these key risks may be measured on a standalone basis, or consolidated for qualitative or quantitative analysis. The analysis of these risks will form a risk profile for the pension plan. These key risks will be monitored and reported using customized pension risk metrics (e.g., metrics on asset-liability matching, longevity, actuarial methods and assumptions, etc) in the PRRS.

Ideas in Action

The PRRS will provide concise and 'at-a-glance' reporting of pension risks; these should be reviewed at least twice a year. The CARR report should be reviewed and revised when circumstances warrant it (e.g. the external risk landscape has materially changed, or the strategic risk positioning risk appetite of the enterprise has been revised by the Board), or at the latest every three years. (For supplemental reading, please refer to Volume 27 of the Ideas Newsletter).

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.