Home / Ideas Letter

Pension Risk – Solution to the 60/40 Risk Dilemma

This article discusses the solution to optimally managing the risk inherent in a traditional asset allocation, 60% equities and 40% bonds, portfolio.

Ideas Letter · Vol. 33 · Sep 2012

Background

The underlying assumptions in a traditional asset allocation study are that markets are largely efficient , returns are randomly (normally) distributed over time, volatility (standard deviation of returns) defines risk, stocks and bonds reliably diversify one another (correlations are stable),and rebalancing of assets to the target allocations constitute the best form of risk management. These assumptions also result in a tilted view that equity risk premium prevail over the long term, and historical long-term average returns are indifferent to economic regimes. The overall result is that most pension plans end up with a 60/40 portfolio and are not optimal from a risk management perspective.

Solution to the 60/40 Risk Dilemma

Any asset allocation study must be supplemented by an asset liability study using an alternative approach – an approach that seeks to deviate from the underlying traditional assumptions- this is difficult to do as this would be ‘bucking’ consensus thinking. An alternative approach would be to use risk categories and risk factors rather than using asset classes as building blocks in your asset liability study. For clarification, asset classes are risk exposures bundled into categories such as equities and bonds based on their financial characteristics (asset owner or lender); even though these asset classes appear diverse, their risk exposures overlap and are not as they appear – this can be seen when asset class are decomposed into risk categories and risk factors exposures. An illustrative sampling of risk categories would include macroeconomic (GDP growth, productivity, inflation, volatility), regional (sovereign, currency, emerging market), developed economy (market size, value, momentum), fixed income (duration, credit, default, capital structure) and other (liquidity, commodities, private market).

An important step is also to assess the risk factors associated with the liabilities. For example, if accounting-based liabilities are measured, then the credit spread risk factor would be incorporated to measure the impact of the credit spread inherent in the discount rate (typically an AA bond) on the long-term duration of liability cash-flows. A simple portfolio can be constructed using returns and correlations among these risk factors. There are practical challenges to constructing purely risk-factor based portfolios, therefore, hybrid approaches can be used. For example, you can examine asset classes using a risk-factor lens but using a single risk category (macroeconomics), or analyse asset class behaviour under inflation and economic growth scenarios and better understand the risk profile.

Ideas in Action

The building of portfolios using risk categories and risk factors as a supplement to a traditional asset allocation study generates a more granular, robust and meaningful asset liability study. The approach enhances the monitoring of risk exposures and attribution of risk more effectively at the asset class level; it can also provide clarity on the potential risk factor exposures inherent within a manager structure. (For supplemental reading refer to Volume 25 of our Newsletter)

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.

↑