Home / Ideas Letter

Pension Risk – Understanding Risks in Supplemental Pension Plans...Part I

This article discusses the risks present in supplemental pension plans and ways to managing these risks.

Ideas Letter · Vol. 13 · Feb 2011

Background

Supplemental Pension Plans (“SPP”) collectively incorporate plans that provide pensions in excess of the maximum pension limits prescribed under the Income Tax Act, and pension arrangements for highly compensated individuals, or executives which are independent of the Income Tax Act. SPP are not registered with the provincial pension regulators, or Canada Revenue Agency, although, SPP have to comply with Salary Deferral Arrangement rules. Due to lack of formal registration or reporting requirements, there is a tendency to believe that here are no risks inherent in SPP. Unfortunately, SPP have significant risks that have to be managed: Design, Governance, Financial and Compliance. In addition, there a multitude of other risks which have a minimal impact but which also need to be understood and considered: Communication, Administration and Counterparty. In Part I, we will discuss Design and Governance risks and potential actions to mitigate these risks.

Design and Governance Risk in Supplemental Pension Plans

Design risk is the risk of SPP design not meeting the company’s philosophy and objectives. SPP is intended to provide a competitive level of total compensation in combination with other compensation, or designed to attract and retain executives, and ensure that plan features ‘lock-in’ executives to the company for a long tenure. It is evident that many SPP designs do not have clearly articulated policy on the purpose of the pension arrangement resulting in designs that do not meet specified objectives. Governance risk is the risk due to the lack of structure, process and documentation. SPP may be established for individuals, or executives who are beneficiaries as well as fiduciaries; therefore, it is imperative that there is an independent and objective governance structure and well-defined process to prudently manage the SPP for its intended purpose and the documentation is clear and complete incorporating a conflict of interest policy. The lack of governance process and documentation will result in litigation as well as loss of reputation and confidence among shareholders and investors.

Ideas in Action

Companies sponsoring SPP should have a clearly articulated policy outlining the purpose of the SPP; this should be properly documented and actively managed. The governance of these plans should ensure that any design variance from the purpose is clearly thought out, justified and documented to ensure no real or perceived conflict of interest. Keeping to a consistent primary purpose will minimize risk and result in effective SPP design, easily understood plan features and simple plan administration.

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.

↑