Home / Ideas Letter

Risk Review: Is your CARR a Lemon?

This article discusses the importance of undertaking a Comprehensive Actuarial Risk Review

Ideas Letter · Vol. 8 · Sep 2010

(CARR).

Background

All companies practice risk management; As a minimum, at least on an annual basis, the risk manager assesses and evaluates the companies’ risk programs and implements loss minimization strategies, or purchases insurance to cover certain risks. The management and Board usually have a fragmented, incomplete and inconsistent understanding of the company’s risk landscape and the reporting is poor. In order to have a holistic and complete view of the risk landscape, a comprehensive actuarial risk review is necessary (Note: As a rule, pension actuaries assess and evaluate pension plan risks and/or determine contribution strategy at least every three years).

Comprehensive Risk Report

Risk in company’s business units is identified, evaluated, assessed and managed on a ‘silo’ basis taking into account their specific circumstances, that is, independent of other business units. It is important to review and manage risk across business units in a consistent manner. A risk review should clearly outline the purpose and objectives of the review; the review objectives (and subsequent decisions and recommendations) should incorporate the strategic context, culture and risk appetite of the company. Although, the risk review is deemed to be ‘comprehensive’, the risk review must focus on risk exposures that significantly and materially impact the balance sheet, comprehensive income statement, cash flows and intellectual capital (human resources). It is important to identify risk metrics that provide clear, concise and accurate indication and measure of risk. A comprehensive risk metric must have the following key attributes: it should be simple – easily determinable, specific- quantifiable using available data, reliable – able to rank risk exposures, rigour – have actuarial and statistical validity and time sensitive - applicable over a determined time horizon

Ideas in Action

A comprehensive actuarial risk review must be strategically undertaken at least every three years or earlier if the strategic risk positioning, or appetite of the company has been revised by the Board. A tactical review must be undertaken every year to confirm and validate the key risk exposures, risk measures and tactical actions. In order to have a clear understanding of the comprehensive risk review report, all actuarial assumptions, data assumptions and limitations, and actuarial methods must be clearly documented in the report, and other risk reports so that your report is not a lemon! .

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.

↑