Home / Ideas Letter

Enterprise Risk Management – Applying Behavioural Science to Risk Management

This article discusses how enterprises can apply behavioural science principles to risk management.

Ideas Letter · Vol. 56 · Sep 2014

Background

There are extensive research studies on risk and risk-taking behaviour. These research studies discuss individual risk-taking behaviour in finance; unfortunately, there is limited information on risk-taking behaviour within an enterprise risk management framework. In this article, we discuss decision-making and risk-taking behaviour theories/concepts, and discuss its applicability to an enterprise.

Applying Behavioural Science to Risk Management

In the field of finance, the classical model of rational decision making continues to be used; in other words, an individual is rational if that person selects the most preferred choice – maximizing utility (maximizer) or value (usually wealth). The view is that classical decisions are based on well-informed systematic processes, acting in their own self-interest in a world of certainty. This notion is extended to enterprises, that is, they act rationally, predictably and in an unbiased manner (self-interest), therefore, classical concepts (e.g. discount models) can be applied in realm of risk management (ignoring whether you agree or disagree with the classical theory). The alternative perspective in finance is the behavioural decision theory (BDT) which provides a more descriptive and realistic model of human behaviour. Under BDT, individuals systematically violate rationality by miscalculating (underestimating or overestimating), and making choices based on non-economical/non-financial factors – the decision-making is influenced by the individual on his/her perception of a given situation, event or circumstance. In risk management, enterprises implicitly apply BDT; in other words, enterprises use heuristics (rules of thumb), display bias, and act based on emotional factors. Most risk decision makers in enterprises are satisficers (act in a way as to satisfy the minimum requirements for achieving a particular result) rather than maximizers. Under BDT, there are some key theories/concepts relevant to enterprise risk decision-making that enterprises should be aware of: Prospect Theory – an entity is loss averse, and more concerned with losses than gains; decision-makers will assign more significance to avoiding a loss than achieving a gain. Heuristics (rules of thumb) – an entity is biased by information that is vivid, well-publicized, recent and easy to recall-therefore, an entity will judge degree of risk as highly probable or frequent if examples are easy to remember or visualize. Anchoring – an entity latches on to a belief that may or may not be truthful but uses it as a reference point for making decisions- for example, an entity may make a decision on projected sales of a product based on the recent past sales ignoring other potential factors ( e.g. new competitor, availability of a better product in the marketplace). Representativeness – an entity tends to make judgements based on similarity of items, or predict future uncertain events by taking a small portion of data and drawing a holistic conclusion.

Ideas in Action

Enterprises must ensure that BDT theories/ concepts are understood and incorporated in risk decision-making framework; the use of BDT will lead to optimal risk solutions and effective risk management.

Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter April 2012, Volume 28.

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.

↑