Enterprise Risk Management – Making Risk Management Relevant at the Board Level
This article discusses how enterprises can make risk management relevant at the Board level.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 55 · Aug 2014
Background
Today, Board members are well aware of importance of managing risks explicitly and having the ability to handling risk issues at the Board level. However, very few Boards fully appreciate the concept of Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) that is, maximizing enterprise value by managing risks holistically across the enterprise.
Making Risk Management Relevant
Risk management differs across industry and business models; however, there are key universal themes:
1 Most Boards delegate audit committees to deal with risk management - interestingly, audit committees primarily focus on risks related to legal and regulatory compliance leaving business risks (in the broader sense) with the full Board. Unfortunately, the ambiguity of dealing with compliance –related and business risks in this manner results in inappropriate risk management at the Board level. All Board meetings should have an explicit agenda item pertaining to ERM. Such an agenda item would specifically address the existence of effective processes for identifying, assessing and mitigating all risks. Boards must oversee, be responsible and accountable for risk management across the enterprise.
2. Most Boards believe that ERM responsibility resides with the CEO as s/he is overall ( directly or indirectly) responsible for managing the business units and line managers with risk responsibility. This is an effective approach as long as CEO has in-house risk expertise (e.g., Risk Officer) ensuring that an appropriate ERM framework is being used, robust ERM processes have been implemented and risk management functions are properly implemented and working at the business units and line functions.
This provides transparency to the Board ( via management) that risk tolerances are clearly applied, the right tools are in place to support risk decision-making and line mangers are effectively managing risks.
3. Boards should be engaging outside expertise to provide periodic independent assessment of the enterprises’ risk management processes and its effectiveness. Such an assessment would provide real and practical insights on how the enterprise compares against industry peers and other industries, and also provide best industrial practices that can be implemented to enhance enterprise value.
Ideas in Action
Boards should have a clear reporting requirement – Is risk review a regular item on the agenda? What risks does the Board need to understand on a regular basis? How often should the risks be reviewed? In what context is the Board reviewing the – compliance or business? Which committee is reviewing the risks? Is external expertise being used to supplement the review of key risks? A risk review report should be prepared periodically prioritizing key risk issues providing management’s assessment of the risk, trade-offs and management’s decision pertaining to the risks, and their rationale. The institutionalizing of risk review as a formal board process will ensure risk management’s relevancy at the Board level.
Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter March 2014, Volume 51.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.