Enterprise Risk Management – Avoiding Herd Risk
This article discusses the concept of herd risk and an approach to avoid herd risk.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 18 · Jun 2011
Background
Our behaviour is to do what everyone else is doing – a type of herd mentality where individuals and corporations are influenced by others to adopt certain behaviours, or undertake actions that can be justified by actions of others. For example, if you are waiting at a walk signal with three seconds to go and you see a number of individuals crossing the road, you may feel safer and more comfortable crossing the road following someone else’s decision. This is also true for corporations- your company may follow certain business actions (e.g., use of exotic hedging strategy) just because your peer companies have used similar actions- the company believes that their actions are validated and justifiable as others have used it. A quote by Anonymous “Those who stray from the herd, risk being left behind, even if the herd head s off to a cliff” suggests that the majority action is deemed to be correct. In our view, understanding and learning from the actions of others may be critical and unavoidable but the implementation of these actions may not translate into an optimal solution or action. Optimal solutions always align with company’s philosophy, strategic intent, objectives and risk appetite.
Avoiding Herd Risk
The 2008 crisis within the financial industry was a recent and best example of herd risk. Simply stated, “herd risk” is the downside risk of implementing mainstream actions and strategies that have little or no alignment to the company’s philosophy, strategic intent, objectives and risk appetite. Companies should clearly articulate the expected actions in their business plans. The best practice is to undertake quarterly, mid-term and annual review to compare the actual actions with the desired or expected actions; the variance must be completely explained in terms of qualitative and quantitative impact on the business. It is critical to learn from the actions of the peer companies – this means that you should theoretically determine the potential impact of the peer companies’ actions if these actions were applied to your company. The comparison of your qualitative and quantitative results using your actions and potential results using peer company actions gives you the variance, or herd risk.
Ideas in Action
The annual business plan must be clear on strategy, actions and expected results. Quarterly or mid-term reviews must be undertaken so that ‘tweaks’ and adjustment can be made over the course of the year. The overarching principle is to obtain and get results aligned with company philosophy and objectives and not be unduly influenced by the herd- this is the basis for an optimal solution.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.