Pension Risk and Enterprise Risk Management –Knowing Your Risk Style
This article discusses the risk styles prevalent in pension plan management within an enterprise risk framework.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 17 · May 2011
Background
Based on our consulting experience, we have come across a number of practical risk styles in managing pension risk; these are not documented in literature but we have concisely summarized them here.
Knowing Your Risk Style
We have categorized five risk styles below. We will briefly discuss each of these styles noting that the enterprise may exhibit and implement a risk style that is appropriate in a specific circumstance.
Risk Aversion: This has been the prevalent style where pension plan risk does not materially impact the enterprise; the actions are usually linked to having ‘reasonable and well defined’ long term asset returns determined on return and risk trade-offs, and obtaining an investment return that is at least equal to the actuarial discount rate.
Risk Optimizers: This style is used to enhance returns over and above the actuarial discount rates using non-traditional strategies; you can spot risk optimization in pension plans by reviewing at the plan’s asset classes– these plans would have introduced non-traditional asset classes such as private equity, infrastructure, or other return enhancing and derivative strategies.
Value Enhancers: This is an emerging category among pension plans. This style results in optimal sharing and transferring of risks (e.g. by use of captives, or derivatives), or using “buy-in” investment products from insurance companies. The result could be a reduction of returns for the pension plan, but the style reduces financial and volatility risk, and adds significant value at the enterprise level.
Risk Eliminators: This style is increasingly used in pension plans that may have a significant impact on enterprise value. You can usually spot risk eliminators among pension plans by reviewing their asset / liability strategies – these plans focus on liability matching strategies, and establishment of minimum risk portfolios. The idea is to minimize financial risk impact at the enterprise level.
Risk Avoiders: This style is prevalent in emerging corporations and competitive industries. This style results in elimination of the pension plan in its entirety, or a ‘buy-out’ (bulk buy-out, or annuity purchase) strategy for the pension plan.
Ideas in Action
It is important to understand your (corporate) risk style in respect of the pension plan. Select the risk style that may be applicable for your circumstance; develop actions that are in the context of your risk style and consistent with your enterprise risk framework – then implement! This will lead to optimal strategies and results that are easily explainable and communicable to stakeholders.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.