Enterprise Risk Management – Managing Pension Risk within ERM
This article discusses the concepts of managing pension risk within an enterprise risk management.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 21 · Sep 2011
Background
There are numerous ERM frameworks in the public domain, for example, the Australian and New Zealand standard, COSO- Integrated ERM, Canadian ERM Standard, ISO standard plus other proprietary frameworks. It is important to realize that all these ERM frameworks incorporate traditional risk management components (that is risk identification, assessment and measurement). Additionally, these ERM frameworks are expanded to include risk strategy, risk objectives and risk policy, that is, understanding risk appetite and tolerance, including clear reporting and robust monitoring. More importantly, risk management under ERM is undertaken across all business units (which usually exclude pension plans) in a consistent, common and uniform manner. The end result is to manage and increase the enterprise value without incorporating the explicit ‘value’ of the enterprises’ pension plans.
Managing Pension Risk within ERM
Typically, pension risks are often equated to “volatility” in asset-liability modelling or study; unfortunately, the measurement of these pension risks are done in isolation of the enterprise and the relationship between the pension plan and the enterprise is overlooked. For example, pension plan liability is very sensitive to interest rate changes. If interest rates go down due to a weakened economy then the value of pension liabilities increase; however, the weakened economy may have a negative impact on the financial operation of the company causing the company not to have the desired cash flow to make required contributions to the pension plan. Also, more generally, equity risk in pension investments tend to be correlated with most plan sponsors’ financial well-being, so equity risk tends to cause good times to be better and bad times to be worse. Another way of saying this is that if equity risk is positively correlated with the plan sponsors’ finances, then there may be greater risk than simple asset-liability volatility measures would suggest. Therefore, it is important to define, map, quantify and consolidate these risks at the enterprise level.
Ideas in Action
Pension plans are complex regulated entities but managing on a standalone basis is not an optimal strategy. Plan sponsors should define components of pension risk and enterprise risk (e.g., market risk, credit risk, operational risk, etc) within a single consistent ERM framework so that risks can be quantified and acted upon consistently and uniformly. – in other words, the application of the mitigation strategy and the actions has the desired economies of scale and impact in a cost effective manner.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.