Home / Ideas Letter

Pension Risk– Managing Defined Contribution Plan Risk

This article discusses pension risks in Defined Contribution (DC) Plans and managing of these DC risks.

Ideas Letter · Vol. 22 · Oct 2011

Background

DC Plans collectively include money purchase plans, group RRSP, TFSA and savings plans. Currently DC plans are primarily established using a competitive perspective, that is, employers select contribution rates based on an acceptable range competitive contribution rates. Employers lack an adequate understanding of the intended portion of the employee’s retirement income it is expecting to provide based on sound and acceptable investment return assumptions. Employers (incorrectly) believe that DC plans have no risk to employers; some (incorrectly) believe that by following the CAP guidelines (2004) they are prudently managing DC plan risks.

Managing DC Pension Risk

Typically, DC Plan risks can be categorized into the following key risks:

-Design: Risk of providing less than the intended level of retirement income; this risk requires that employers clearly articulate and document the level of income they expect to deliver to employees

- Communication / Education: Risk of inadequate or unclear communication; this risk requires that customized and specific employer plan information is communicated, and satisfactory education is provided regarding accumulation scenarios, drawdown scenarios, loss of purchasing power, longevity, and hedging and risk transfer mechanisms( for example, annuity purchase)

-Governance: Risk due to lack of structure, policies and processes; this risk is managed by having clear documentation, actively management of investment options and regularly reviewing the DC plan

-Investment Return: Risk of not achieving the desired or target level of return; this risk can be managed by initially communicating the employer’s objective of income delivery, and subsequently providing tools to employees in achieving or exceeding the employer’s desired or target return

-Inflation: Risk of losing purchasing power during the accumulation and draw-down phases; this risk is difficult to manage as employees are not receptive to discussion of inflationary expectations during periods of stagnant growth and deflationary sentiments; continuous education is the key response.

-Longevity: Risk of outliving employee savings; this risk can be managed by educating employees on available risk transfer products such as annuity and providing access to such products.

Ideas in Action

Actively management of the key DC risks will minimize the potential of litigation and reputational risk.

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.