Home / Ideas Letter

Enterprise Risk Management - Maximizing Enterprise Value

This article discusses enterprise value and the concept of 'cost of risk’ in maximizing enterprise value.

Ideas Letter · Vol. 43 · Jul 2013

Background

The overarching corporate goal in most organizations is to maximize enterprise value for equity investors - persons, or entities who supply equity capital for the purpose of receiving the maximum return within the mandate of the enterprises' business. Of course, different stakeholders (equity investors, debt holders, employees, etc) all have different values at stake and different attitudes to risk. Fortunately, the 'cost of risk' is universally applicable in determination of enterprise value for all stakeholders. In maximizing enterprise value, an enterprise will pursue business or projects in which the rate of return is greater than the cost of capital. From a practical perspective, the enterprise will seek to maximize the discounted net cash flow which indirectly infers minimizing of expected losses - a key goal of most risk management processes. At a minimum, an enterprise will seek to understand events that will damage its financial performance and creditworthiness, and mitigate against such events.

Maximizing Enterprise Value and Cost of Risk

An enterprise is exposed to a range of financial and non-financial risks. These risks can impact enterprise value by affecting expected net cash flows through severity, timing and variability; these risks can be managed by risk management processes such as loss control(e.g., safety), loss financing(e.g., insurance, self-insurance), risk reduction( e.g. withdrawal, diversification) and risk transfer( e.g. outsource) - of course, these are only achievable at a cost ('cost of risk')-the implicit or explicit price paid to manage such risk exposures , therefore, cost of risk directly affects enterprise value as it impacts operating income. Ideally, cost of risk comprises of the expected cost of direct and indirect losses from retained losses, expected cost of loss control activities, expected cost of financing activities, expected cost of risk reduction activities, and expected cost of risk transfer activities. The ultimate goal of a value maximizing enterprise must be the minimizing of cost of risk- this is not necessarily the same as minimizing risk. All other things being equal, an enterprise will reduce its variability of expected net cash flow and reduce its operating income if it spends more on the cost of risk. At some point, the marginal cost of the risk management activity will be greater than the expected losses; when this occurs, the enterprise may have eliminated all its risk and become 'risk-free' but the enterprise is unlikely to have yielded an enterprise with a maximized value. Risk minimization does not translate to value maximization.

Ideas in Action

All enterprises must make decisions regarding management of risks and how they will impact enterprise value. An enterprise will decide on investing in loss control activities, or financing loss financing activities if the enterprise has sufficient funds for such activities. Alternatively, the enterprise may consider reducing or transferring of risk if the enterprise has the ability or capacity to diversify, or share risks; each of these decisions must be analyzed by determining the cost of risk, evaluated using cost/benefit techniques, and with explicit tradeoffs considered and its impact on enterprise value.

Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter February 2012, Volume 26.

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.