Pension Risk - Right-Risking Solutions
This article discusses the concept of de-risking and introduces right-risking to manage pension risk.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 42 · Jun 2013
Background
In Canada, there is an increasing trend to de-risking plans to manage pension risk. Unfortunately, de-risking has different meanings; on one hand, de-risking is a cash-flow matching approach that is, matching of pension cash-flows with income (cash flow) from fixed income securities. On the other hand, de-risking is an interest rate-matching approach that is, matching of pension liability and pension assets in changes in interest rate at specific durations. The term de-risking is also used to capture capital market and insurance solutions (buy-in, buy-out, swaps, and hedging or annuity purchases). The key reasons for de-risking is to manage pension cost volatility, and ensure the security of benefits for pension plan members in the longer term. De-risking is a valid and acceptable concept then the question is why introduce the concept of right-risking? What is right-risking?
Right-Risking Solutions
There are prevailing sentiments among pension practitioners that, either cash-flow matching, or interest-rate matching can fully de-risk pension plans; generally, it is impossible and impractical to 'zero' out all the risks. Also, there are certain risks that are difficult to hedge, e.g., longevity risk cannot be fully hedged due use of population based indices, or pensions based on final average salaries or indexation are close to impossible to hedge. To some extent, purchase of annuities manages cost-volatility and ensures benefit security for members. By their nature, pension plans will always have residual risks that cannot be 'hedged ' away, or purchased using an insurance solution. Right-risking solutions attempt to de-risk the plans and offset the residual risks by use of investment solutions. An appropriate approach would require segregation of liability into specific 'buckets'; certain liability buckets ( e.g., pensioner liability, 'fixed' pensions) would be optimally managed to 'close to eliminate' pension risks using de-risking techniques; other buckets (e.g., very long -term active liability) where residual risk is present would be managed by applying optimal investment solutions (i.e., enhancing investment returns using real estate, private equity, infrastructure, or absolute return strategies) . Whatever, right-risking technique is used, it is important to ensure that level of pension risk is managed in the overall context of the risk-appetite of the enterprise. If your enterprise has a higher risk threshold (appetite), it may be appropriate to match a small proportion of your liability buckets using fixed income securities or, more refined matching techniques can be used for a lower risk threshold.
Ideas in Action
Before right-risking solutions are implemented, it is best to return to basics, and understand the inherent risks in your pension plan. You need t to validate these risks and confirm your risk management policy and strategy; specifically, you must confirm that the actions you are implementing (or have implemented) actually reduce or mitigate pension risks. Once these actions have been implemented, the best risk practice is to ensure you are closely monitoring and reporting the key pension risk indicators.
Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter May 2013, Volume 41.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.