Enterprise Risk Management – More lessons from the Japanese Disaster
This article highlights more lessons we can learn for the Fukushima Disaster. The earlier lessons learnt were articulated in the Lalani Ideas Letter- July 2011, Volume 19.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 31 · Jul 2012
Background
The official report of the Fukushima Nuclear Independent Accident Investigation Commission was published recently. From a risk perspective, the key excerpt from the Commission’s report was “...we conclude that the accident was ‘manmade’. We believe that the root causes were the organizational and regulatory systems that supported faulty rationales for decisions and actions...”
More Lessons from the Disaster
It is clear from the Commission’s report that there was evidence that the organization and regulators were aware of the Tsunami risk and the potential for extensive damage; however, no measures were taken to lessen or eliminate the risk because the probability of the event was deemed to be “small” and the regulators failed to provide guidance to remedy the situation. There are two lessons that can be learnt: it is not unusual for organizations to ignore risks that have low likelihood of occurrence. This omission can be explained by the fact that organizations focus on the “event” instead of considering risk collectively as the event, cause and the impact or consequence – this provides a better approach of identifying multiple causes and impacts from a single event. Another lesson is that blind acceptance or compliance of a regulatory review does not provide the necessary safeguards for a risk management process. It is essential that all proper risk procedures and controls are internally implemented, and all risks are adequately monitored and assessed independent of regulatory assessments.
It is also apparent from the Commission’s report that the disaster could be labelled “Made in Japan” due to ingrained conventions of Japanese culture of reflexive obedience, reluctance to question authority and devotion to ‘sticking to the program’. The key lesson to be learnt: Organizations should have a risk culture that supports feedback, challenge and questioning of engrained risk management processes. Such a risk culture would require that executives and management are also committed to risk management – in other words, management inform employees that non-compliant or reckless risk behaviour will not be tolerated; and application and implementation of good and sound risk practices implementation is rewarded and recognized. In addition, employees should have access to management to voice their opinions, or concerns on risk issues without any reprisals. The key element of an organization’s risk culture should ensure “doing the right things” over “doing whatever it takes”
Ideas in Action
It is critical that organizations review their risk definition, and expand it to incorporate event, cause and consequence. This would allow for better assessment, measurement, communication and monitoring of risk and avoid a “manmade” disaster. Executives and management should also set the proper tone on risk and incorporate risk management processes in the day-to-day responsibilities of an employee.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.