ERM – Is Your Organization an Enterprise Risk Management Company?
This article highlights the key questions you can ask to ascertain whether your organization is an Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) company.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 30 · Jun 2012
Background
Our recent review of Management Discussion and Analysis (MD&A) documents for public companies highlighted an interested fact - most companies stated that they were pursuing ERM. This interesting fact generated an even more compelling question- are these companies really pursuing ERM? Based on our assessment of the MD&A of many public companies and our consulting experience, the short answer is “No - most organizations pursue risk management on a ‘silo’ basis for non-strategic risks and do not manage risk systematically across the enterprise. You can determine whether your organization is pursuing ERM by answering two simple questions.
Enterprise Risk Management Company
Does you organization have a risk policy? The key purpose for establishing ERM is to ensure that the organization’s business strategy and objectives are supported by effective and uniform risk management practices across business units and departments. A risk policy would incorporate standard risk processes for the following: initiation, identification, evaluation, management, reporting and monitoring. In addition, the risk policy would clearly articulate the organization’s risk appetite (‘the level of risk that an organization is prepared to accept, before action is deemed necessary to reduce it’), risk tolerance (‘the specific maximum risk that the organization is willing to take for specific categories of risk such as strategic, financial, operational, regulatory, and other risks defined within an organization’s ERM framework’) and risk target ( maximum level of risk acceptable for a specific risk , for example, interest rate, commodity, etc within the financial risk component at the business unit or department level).
Does your organization have a risk culture? The key component of an ERM framework is the existence of a risk culture within an enterprise. Risk culture can be defined as the system of values and behaviours that shape risk decisions. An organization with a risk culture influences the decisions of the board, management and employees even if they are not consciously weighing risks and benefits. One element of a risk culture is having well defined s risk taxonomy standard- “risk speak”- this allows for easy communication, discussion and monitoring of risk among everyone in an enterprise. If your organization does not have risk taxonomy standard then it is unlikely that you have well established ERM practices.
Ideas in Action
As a Board member or management you should ask the two questions. If the answer to either of them is negative then your organization is probably not an ERM company. If the answers to both the questions are positive, then your organization is managing risk well and on its way to becoming an ERM company.
Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter- January 2011, Volume 12
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.