Home / Ideas Letter

Enterprise Risk Management – Understanding Operational Risk

This article discusses the definition, causes and management of operational risk.

Ideas Letter · Vol. 49 · Jan 2014

Background

Operational risks is present in our day-to-day life – recent examples, include egregious fraud (Madoff), unauthorized trading (USB), insider trading (Nomura), technological failings (Nasdaq Facebook IPO) and external events (tsunamis) - these events cause enterprises and individuals to lose millions of dollars. The important point is that operational risk results in losses comparable to other enterprises risks (market, credit, financial, etc.) and should be understood and managed with the same rigour as such other risks and embedded in the culture of the enterprise.

Definition, Causes, and Management

In the past, operational risk was defined as all risks that were not captured in market and credit risk; the view taken was that if it was not market risk and it was not credit risk, then it must be operational risk! Today, a more concrete definition has been established defining operational risk as the risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed processes, people and systems or from external events (Basel II definition). Most enterprises have adopted the Basel II definition, however, some have adopted this definition with minor tweaks (for example replacing ‘people’ with ‘human factors’ in the definition).

The Basel guidelines provides seven categories of events which allow us to understand the causes of operational risk (items in brackets are examples of the causes or contributory factors) : internal fraud (losses due to defrauding acts), external fraud (losses to circumvent the law), employment practices and workplace safety (losses from inappropriate acts in the workplace), clients, products and business practices (losses from negligence and failure to meet professional standards), damage to physical assets (losses from natural disaster), business disruptions and system failure (losses due to poor back-up systems), execution, delivery and process management( losses from poor relationship with counterparties). As with other risks, operational risk incorporates three dimensions – contributory factors, events and consequences. Contributory factors are items that should have been done and were not done (background environment), and events represent items that happened that generated a loss. In practice, a “cause” and “effect” model works well to managing operational risk- this is done by combing the contributory risks and events as “causes” and the consequences as “effects”, thereby, setting proper control systems to managing the causes and effects. The “causes” are then categorized as control issues (e.g., what controls does the enterprise need to put in place to avoid the contributory factors and event?), and “effects” are categorized as damage controls (e.g., how actions do you need to undertake as a result of the causes to minimize or reduce potential monetary and non-monetary losses).

Ideas in Action

A better understanding of operational risk and implementing of a robust framework allows for informed decision making, avoiding ‘bad’ surprises, and equipping the enterprise with tools and contingency planning to respond when an event occurs. An enterprise should reviewing their operational risk framework and its effectiveness. Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter August 2012, Volume 32.

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.

↑