Operational Risk Management – Application to Pension Plans
This article discusses the application of Operational Risk Management to Pension Plans.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 50 · Feb 2014
Background
Operational Risk is not a standalone risk but a collection of independent, correlated and uncorrelated risks. Similarly, Operational Risk in pension plans comprises of a number of risks attributable to failed processes, incorrect or inaccurate systems, poor governance, out-of date policies and documentation, inadequate vendor management, insufficient communication with stakeholders, and ineffective audit practices. Having noted that operational risks are inherent in pension plans – the question is whether Operational Risk has material and meaningful impact in a pension plan? The short answer is ‘yes’.
Application of Operational Risk Management to Pension Plans
The operation of a pension plan can be illustrated by a simple equation C + I = B + E. Contributions(C) are remitted into a pension fund and invested into asset classes to produce investment returns (I) which over the long term will pay out pension benefits (B) to plan members and expenses (E) for pension plan management and administration. For most pension plans, 70% of the left side of the equation is attributed to investment returns, and 90% of the right hand side of the equation is attributed to benefit payments. Most pension plans focus their efforts in managing financial risks (which encompasses market and investment risks) and ignore risks related to benefits (B) which are primarily operational risks since these risks are deemed to be insignificant. The fact is that operational pension risks (‘OPR’) do not exhibit the ‘in-your-face’ risk attributes of volatility, market comparability and benchmarking as is the case with financial risk. OPR is ‘latent’ risk – the risk exists but is not yet evident (it is hidden or concealed), or the risk has yet to be developed or manifested. As an example, incorrect benefit payments due to administrative or system errors, misinterpretation of plan provisions, or inadequate processes may be apparent or uncovered after a prolonged period (3-5 years) and only if certain audit procedures or controls discover this error. Similarly, inadequate segregation of duties among pension committee members results in lack of accountability, and the lack of well-defined contractual vendor agreements results in poor service levels for plan members - both of these contributory factors and events will result in reputational consequences with stakeholders. In order to manage latent pension risks, it is prudent to apply the “Cause” and “Effect” operational risk model - that Is, understand the contributory factors and events causing the risk, and actions required to minimize or eliminate monetary / non-monetary losses. For OPR, it is important to note that most operational pension risks have a low likelihood of occurrence and the impact or consequences range from low to high impact.
Ideas in Action
There are a significant number of important pension plan activities and tasks that are undertaken daily or periodically; all these activities and tasks have risk associated with them. It is not reasonable to manage all these risks concurrently; we believe that every year not more than five key risks must be identified, prioritized and actioned; once a risk is actioned and dealt with, that is, the risk is shared, transferred, mitigated or eliminated, then only then a new risk is added to the list of five key risks to be managed. Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter January 2014, Volume 49.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.