ERM – Pension Maturity Model
This article discusses pension plan maturity in an Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) context.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 29 · May 2012
Background
The maturity of risk management for a pension plan under ERM can be categorized under one of the four levels of the Pension Maturity Model (PMM) ranging from limited formal risk management to fully integrated risk management. As with all models, very pension plans fit neatly into a specific level, therefore, it is important to benchmark pension risk management against all four levels.
Pension Maturity Model (PMM)
PMM Level I : All enterprises practice risk management in a traditional sense, that is, they exercise business discipline to protecting assets and profits by reducing loss potential, mitigating loss impact, and executing recovery measures after a loss. Such risk management is dealt on a ‘silo’ basis within a business unit (including the pension plan) and cover hazard events (fire, business interruption, etc.) and other specific pension risks (contribution volatility, etc.). Risk management is a reactive exercise.
PMM Level II: Some enterprises may manage risks ‘collaboratively’; there is usually a risk policy identifying the key risks at the enterprise level. All key risks are managed within a business unit or pension plan level and reported to an audit committee. Pension risk management is compliance focussed and quantitative risk measures are limited to comply with pension regulations. There is no aggregation of risks at the enterprise level but risks are coordinated at the enterprise level.
PMM Level III: A few companies manage risks ‘systematically’ with clear articulation of the enterprises’ risk appetite and tolerance with well documented statements serving as the basis for managing risk at the business or pension plan level. There are better defined quantitative risk measures balanced with well thought out qualitative measures, and these are reported to the enterprise’s risk committee.
PPM Level IV: A limited number of companies and standalone pension plans have ‘integrated’ risk management embedded in strategic decision making. The performance of the pension plan is linked to the performance of the enterprise. The Board or senior management use a risk dashboard, or risk scorecard with pension risk measures that ensure optimal risk management. Such an enterprise may have a Chief Risk Officer in the senior management ranks. Risk management is a proactive exercise.
Ideas in Action
Enterprises should evaluate and benchmark their pension risk management practice against the PMM. This would allow the enterprises’ pension plan to enhance the level of risk capability and progress forward to the next maturity level. During evaluation of the pension plan, most enterprises will find that a lack of risk culture is one of the key barriers to progressing to the next maturity level; therefore, it is imperative to embed an acceptable risk culture in enterprise before embarking on the PMM journey.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.