Pension Risk: Defining Risk Appetite, Risk Tolerance
This article discusses risk appetite and risk tolerance in a pension plan context.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 26 · Feb 2012
Background
In an ERM context, risk appetite is the level of risk that an enterprise is prepared to accept/take to support its business strategy and objectives. Risk tolerance expresses the maximum level of risk that the enterprise is willing to bear/tolerate for a specific type of risk to achieve its objectives. Since enterprise pension plans are governed by trust laws which are separate and apart from the enterprise, pension plan risk management does not incorporate all of the components of enterprise risk management. In other words, risk appetite and risk tolerance are not terms usually defined in a pension plan context.
Defining Risk Appetite and Tolerance for a Pension plan
Risk appetite for an enterprise pension plan must be defined from two perspectives – plan member’s benefit security, and the enterprise (plan sponsor) financial capability. As an example, risk appetite for a pension plan may state that the pension contributions will be set at a target level of x% of earnings but will never be less that pension contributions to maintain the solvency ratio (that is, ratio of pension liability and pension assets) at less than y%. This is an example of risk appetite definition from an earnings perspective. Other definitions from a capital/balance sheet could also be developed based on the stated business objectives. A well documented funding policy and results of an asset liability study would provide the required components for developing an effective risk appetite measure.
Pension plans are subject to on-going risks due to economic variables: investment return (discount rate) cost of living increases, earnings increases, and demographic variables: longevity, incidence of retirement and termination rates. Key risks that materially impact the financial stability of pension plan have to be identified and assessed. Risk tolerances for these key risks are set at an acceptable level to ensure financial stability at the pension plan and enterprise level. As an example, risk tolerance measure for investment return would state that the return from pension assets will not be less than a real rate (net of inflation) of z%. For an investment return measure, the asset allocation policy would provide the required information for developing a risk tolerance measure. For demographic risks, the information from actuarial valuation reports particularly the gain and loss analysis supplemented by scenario analysis (for longevity risk) would be an excellent starting point for developing risk tolerance measures.
Ideas in Action
The board through its pension board or pension committee should set the risk appetite in respect of the pension plan, and set the risk tolerance for each key pension risk. The board should formally review the risk appetite and risk tolerance measures annually to ensure that they remain appropriate for the pension plan and the enterprise in light of on-going internal and external factors.
Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter November 2010, Volume 10
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.