Pension Risk – The Risk in Current ALM Practice
This article discusses the risk in using Asset Liability Management of pension plans, in isolation from the plan sponsor’s business.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 25 · Jan 2012
Background
The pension plan has historically been managed on a stand-alone ‘silo’ basis rather than holistically at the enterprise level. This has been due to a number of factors: until recently, pension assets and liabilities were off-balance sheet and not disclosed fully as is currently required under IFRS pension accounting standards, the regulatory structure of pension trusts which require pension plans to be asymmetrical in nature (employer contributions are required but surplus cannot be redirected back to plan sponsor’s business), fiduciary mindset that plan assets are for the beneficiaries and must be managed without consideration of plan sponsor’s interest, and a lack of understanding of the correlation of risk between the pension plan and the enterprise.
Risk in Current ALM Practice
Since the measurement of pension risk in an ALM study is done in isolation of the sponsor, this could result in a number of important risk relations between the pension plan and sponsor being overlooked. For example, plans have significant equity exposure in an attempt to achieve higher longer term returns- the ALM practice fails to consider the correlation of equity risk between the enterprise and pension plan; if the enterprise has a positive beta meaning that the enterprise’s financial performance is positively correlated with stock market returns so if the market falls so does the ability of the sponsor to meet its pension obligations and when the sponsor is least able to afford it. Most ALM is quantitative modelling to help sponsors better understand pension risk. For computational ease, relationships across variables and risk factors are captured in reduced form instead of structural form. The correlation matrix among asset classes which describe the empirical historical relationship between asset returns is an example of reduced form. The model does not capture the structural drivers of asset class returns using current economic information or forecast of current economic data.
Ideas in Action
Plan sponsors should be cognizant of the risks inherent in using ALM study for pension plan in isolation of the enterprise. Failure to evaluate risk in a holistic manner at the enterprise level is likely to understate the plan risks and risk-adjusted costs to the sponsor.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.