Home / Ideas Letter

Pension Risk– Managing Design Risk in Defined Contribution Plans

This article discusses design risk in Defined Contribution (DC) Plans.

Ideas Letter · Vol. 23 · Nov 2011

This article is a follow-up to the October 2011 article on Managing DC Plan Risk.

Background

Typically, DC Plans are established using a competitive perspective by looking at their peer comparators and selecting a contribution rate that seems reasonable and competitive. As an example, the contribution rate (which may include matching or regular contributions from employees) may be set at the median of the DC Plans for comparator companies on the basis that the level of contribution is adequate or neutral for purposes on attracting or retaining employees. The CAP guidelines (2004) require plan sponsors to select investment options for their DC Plans. The guidelines focus on defining the purpose of the DC Plan and selection of the investment options to satisfy the purpose but do not require plan sponsors to articulate a target / desired level of income that is expected to be delivered based on the investment options made available to employees.

Managing Design Risk

When establishing a DC Plan, contribution rates are used to determine replacement ratios (retirement income as a percentage of earnings at retirement) for a sample of profile employees based on a number of deterministic scenarios of investment returns (4% to 9%). Investment options are independently selected to cover the spectrum of risk/reward profiles. The analysis of whether the replacement ratios can actually be delivered with the investment options provided is usually ignored. Plan sponsors should use stochastic modelling to model the target replacement ratios with the range of investment options-such analysis will provide insightful perspective on the likelihood of an employee being able to attain a target replacement ratio at the specified contribution rate and selected investment options.

Ideas in Action

Plan sponsors must have a structured process to monitor the DC Plan design on an annual basis. Annual monitoring should include but not limited to sampling of select profile of employees (with their actual account balances and actual investment options) to model the pension payouts and determine whether these select profiles will meet the stated objectives (with respect to the target level) of the DC Plan. If there is a significant variance between the modelled payout and the target level, a review of the investment options could be considered, or communication and education activities could be increased. An annual monitoring process provides a prudent approach to managing DC design risk.

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.

↑