Pension Risk - Supplemental Pension Plans
This article discusses managing of key pension risks in Supplemental Retirement Plans ( SPP).
Ideas Letter · Vol. 40 · Apr 2013
Background
SPP collectively incorporate plans that provide pensions in excess of the maximum pension limits prescribed under the Income Tax Act, and pension arrangements for highly compensated individuals, or executives which are independent of the Income Tax Act. SPP are not registered with the provincial pension regulators, or Canada Revenue Agency. There are some key risks that need to be managed which are overlooked by plan sponsors.
SPP Risks
There are many risks inherent in SPP, however, the following two key risks require particular attention :
-Design / Compensation : Most companies pride themselves on having a 'total compensation program' incorporating base salary, 'pay at risk' ( short term and long term incentives), benefits and perquisites. The fact is that most companies do not adequately value SPP in their total compensation program, and/or provide SPP as an 'add-on' for executives; the 'add-on' results in excessive compensation for executives ranging from 15%-40% of base salary. If SPP values are calculated, these values are determined using accounting methodology( projected unit credit method) which is inappropriate for determining SPP values(individual level premium method is a more accurate and appropriate method). The lack of sophistication in use of appropriate actuarial methodology results in including lower SPP values in total compensation. It is important to note that inclusion of SPP in total compensation also results in an unintended consequence - decreasing the overall 'pay at risk' for executives.
-Governance : SPP are usually established for individuals, or executives who are beneficiaries as well as fiduciaries. This results in an awkward situation( conflict of interest) especially if these key stakeholders (executives) have an expectation for a pension commitment that is excessive; such a pension commitment may be for pensions in excess of what is adequate from a total compensation standpoint, and pension security ( assets backing the pension liability) which may be costly to the company. SPP requires an independent and objective governance structure with well-defined processes for prudent management of the SPP and incorporating a robust approval process. At most companies, the SPP documentation is poor and incomplete- there is lack of detail on conflict of interest, pension settlement, competitive restrictions, tax equalization provisions and special situations.
Ideas in Action
The Board, or the Human Resources and Compensation Committee ( HRCC) should review their current SPP arrangements and accurately value the SPP portion to determine total compensation, and the impact on 'pay at risk'. In addition, the HRCC should ensure that the SPP arrangements are clearly documented, and all supporting governance documents, including a compensation policy, conflict of interest policy , and plan provisions are complete. The managing of these risks will increase reputation and confidence among shareholders and investors, as reduce litigation by exiting executives.
Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter February 2011, Volumes 13, 14 and March 2011, Volume 15.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.