Pension Risk - Longevity Risk Solutions
This article discusses financial instruments and products to manage and/or hedge longevity risk.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 41 · May 2013
Background
In Canada, there are a lack of financial instruments and products to hedge longevity risks; however, we can learn from capital market and insurance solutions used in the UK. Longevity risk is the 'silent' risk ; the consequence of this risk( increase in pension costs and liabilities) creeps up on the pension plan if little, or no attention is paid to mortality improvements . As a minimum, pension plan sponsors should quantify the impact of longevity risks periodically, and ensure the use of updated mortality assumptions (incorporating mortality improvements) at each actuarial valuation. Prudent pension plan sponsors must also keep abreast of emerging capital market and insurance solutions.
Longevity Risk Solutions
The following capital market and insurance solutions on managing pension (including longevity) risks have emerged in the UK:
-Buy-out : the complete pension plan ( 100% of the asset and liability) is 'sold' (transferred) to a third party usually an insurer, investment bank, or special pension corporation. The buyout transfers all the pension risks including longevity risk from the enterprise to the third party.
-Buy-in: the pension plan purchases a 'bulk' (group) annuity contract with the insurer; the contract is usually with respect to retiree (inactive) liability. The purchase transfers longevity and investment risks for retiree liability to the insurer. The concentration of annuities with a single insurer could give rise to financial risk in event of the insurer's bankruptcy, or insolvency since these pension assets and liabilities are commingled with general assets and liabilities of the insurer.
Longevity Swap contract: the pension plan transfers longevity risk to a counterparty usually an investment bank using a fully collateralized 'over the counter' derivative contract. The contract is a customized contract and very specific to the pension plan in question, therefore, such a contract is not easily transferable to other counterparties resulting in additional counterparty risks.
Longevity Hedge: this is similar to the longevity swap contract but the transfer is to an insurer using an insurance contract. Again, such a contract is customized and is not easy to transfer to another insurer.
Mortality/Survival Index Swap: The longevity risk is transferred to a counterparty with reference to a published index (reference population rather than a specific pool of lives). The hedging cost ( basis) is determined over time as the mortality difference between the reference population and pension plan.
Ideas in Action
Longevity risk is manageable by funding the increase in mortality improvements at each actuarial valuation; however, pension plan sponsors must review their risk profile periodically and optimize pension risk including longevity risk. Although Canada does not have capital market solutions for longevity risk , consideration should be given to the use of lump sum options for transferring longevity risk to plan beneficiaries, and use of annuities to transferring longevity risk to insurers.
Supplemental Reading: Lalani Ideas Letter April 2010, Volume2.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.