Home / Ideas Letter

Pension Risk – Understanding Risks in Supplemental Pension Plans...Part III

This article discusses the risks present in supplemental pension plans and ways to managing these risks.

Ideas Letter · Vol. 15 · Mar 2011

Background

In Part II, we discussed Financial and Compliance risks in Supplemental Pension Plans (“SPP”). In Part III, we will discuss other risks: Communication, Administration and Counterparty.

Communication, Administration and Counterparty Risk in Supplemental Pension Plans

Communication risk is the risk of not communicating the provisions of the supplementary pension plan and employer commitment to executives and covered employee resulting in litigation and loss of reputation both internally and externally. The employer commitment is in respect of company funding (setting aside assets to cover the liabilities) and securing (protecting the pension promise in the event of company’s bankruptcy, insolvency, discontinuance, or other special events). It is critical that companies provide clear and accurate communication to executives and covered employees to minimize communication risks; such information can be incorporated into the annual total compensation / value statement, or sent in a separate communication bulletin, or customized statement.

Administration risk is due to errors and omissions during the administration of the supplementary pension plan. The errors are usually a result of poor documentation of plan provisions and administrative practices, inaccurate data, or incomplete information (for example, the executive may have been promised additional or prior service but documentation may not reflect this commitment). Companies have a tendency of customizing pension arrangements and introducing special provisions for select individuals. The practical solution is to design supplementary arrangements that are consistent and uniform with standard provisions applicable to all individuals. In addition, robust and structured processes, and well documented administrative practices will minimize administration risk.

Counterparty risk is the risk of non-performance of the third party to whom tasks are delegated. The effective solution is to have service agreements and ensure performance is reviewed periodically. Any non-performance should result in re-evaluation of the relationship and possible termination.

Ideas in Action

These risks have minimal financial impact on the company; however, the non-financial consequences, that is, litigation and loss of reputation can result in loss of confidence among employees, executives and other stakeholders. It is imperative that proper consideration is given to such non-financial risks.

Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.

↑