Pension Risk – Revisiting Liability Driven Investments
This article discusses the use of Liability Driven Investment frameworks and process to manage pension risk.
Ideas Letter · Vol. 16 · Apr 2011
Background
Recently, there have been numerous articles on the use of Liability Driven Investments (LDI) frameworks to managing pension risk. Most of the LDI frameworks suggest a process similar to the following: identify the liability benchmark (on-going, solvency, and accounting), identify the minimum risk portfolio, add an acceptable level of investment risk to enhance returns, set a policy benchmark and track the implementation of the policy. The resulting recommendation is usually to extend the duration of the investment portfolio to match the liability duration. The process seems simple and straightforward; unfortunately, the application of the LDI framework misses an important point that the use of the minimum risk portfolio provides a good starting point but it does not provide an accurate basis for ‘minimizing’ pension risk since other critical factors (indexing, post-retirement mortality, pre-retirement demographic and salary) are not appropriately captured, or ignored in such a portfolio.
Revisiting Liability Driven Investments
An LDI study follows similar steps to a classical Asset Liability Study (ALS). However, in an LDI process, a minimum risk portfolio is structured comprising of bonds to immunize investment risk and the impact of such a portfolio on actuarial measures (service cost, unfunded liability) and/or accounting measures (pension cost, accrued liability) is illustrated. Subsequently, other asset classes are added to the portfolio to enhance the returns; these returns are simulated under varying economic scenarios to converge to an acceptable level of investment risk. A rigorous LDI study should incorporate methodology (simple ‘tricks’ and techniques are available) to address other critical pension risks.
Ideas in Action
As a plan sponsor, or decision maker, it is imperative to understand the limitations of LDI. It may minimize risk for certain risk categories; however, it does not optimize the management of risk in a pension plan. An LDI study should consider other critical factors and incorporate these factors in developing of an optimal risk portfolio. Also, as a rule, it is important to ensure that the selected liability benchmark addresses the benefit security and sustainability of the pension plan as an on-going entity over the long-term, and not get focussed or distracted on short term accounting and solvency/wind-up measures unless these are critical and probable events in the short term.
Written for professional readers and reflects my views at the date shown. It is not actuarial, investment or legal advice.